LEXINGTON, S.C. — A judge on Wednesday, Oct. 7, refused to grant post-conviction relief to Treveon Nelson, one of three people convicted in the 2021 kidnapping and killing of 15-year-old Sanaa Amenhotep.
Judge Robert E. Hood ruled against Nelson at the Lexington County Courthouse. Nelson had returned to court to challenge his conviction.
Testifying at the hearing, Nelson said the lawyer who handled his case did not represent him fairly and that he felt pressured by that lawyer to plead guilty instead of taking the case to trial.
Nelson and Jaylen Wilson each pleaded guilty to murder, kidnapping, criminal conspiracy and possession of a weapon during a violent crime, according to an August 2023 release from the 11th Circuit Solicitor’s Office. Nicolle Sanchez-Peralta went to trial and was found guilty of murder and kidnapping by a Lexington County jury. At a sentencing hearing that month, Judge Debra R. McCaslin gave Nelson and Wilson 60 years apiece on the murder count and gave Sanchez-Peralta 65 years. The solicitor’s office said all three sentences must be served in full, without parole, and that prosecutors did not offer or negotiate a plea with any of the defendants.
Amenhotep, a freshman at Richland Northeast High School, went missing from an apartment complex in northeast Richland County on the night of April 5, 2021. Investigators later concluded that the three defendants had taken her in a stolen vehicle to a remote area near Leesville in Lexington County, the solicitor’s office said. Testimony at Sanchez-Peralta’s trial showed the teen was beaten and shot at least 14 times. Her body, buried in a shallow grave, was found on April 28, 2021, after investigators conducted interviews and a wide search.
Appeals in the case continue. Sanchez-Peralta is scheduled to argue before the S.C. Supreme Court next Wednesday that her conviction should be overturned, and Wilson filed a motion of his own seeking post-conviction relief on Oct. 6.
Section: More Lexington SC crime news
Filed under: Lexington SC Public Safety News