Columbia, South Carolina, August 21, 2025
News Summary
The South Carolina Supreme Court has clarified legal proceedings for United Methodist churches seeking disaffiliation from the denomination. The ruling allows cases from eleven disassociated churches to be consolidated in lower courts, enabling a single judge to streamline the process. This decision, amidst ongoing disputes over LGBTQ inclusion and property rights, sets a significant precedent for future church separations, affecting over 200 churches that have disaffiliated since new provisions were introduced.
Columbia, South Carolina – The South Carolina Supreme Court has made a pivotal decision that clarifies the legal proceedings for several United Methodist churches seeking to separate from the denomination. The ruling follows a lawsuit filed in April by eleven churches that disassociated from the United Methodist Church, seeking clarity on their right to separate and the associated property rights.
The Supreme Court stated it would not accept a motion for original jurisdiction, as the matter can be adequately addressed in a lower court. This allows the cases involving the eleven churches to be consolidated into a single proceeding, streamlining the legal process and enabling a single judge to resolve the various issues at hand. Attorney Jim Bannister remarked that this consolidation is a significant development for other congregations considering disaffiliation from the United Methodist Church.
Currently, numerous congregations that wish to leave the United Methodist Church have either formally disassociated or are in the process of doing so. The lawsuits arise from ongoing disputes concerning the church’s policies on LGBTQ inclusion and the status of church properties under the existing trust clause. The United Methodist Church has been experiencing a gradual shift away from the definitions and guidelines established in its “Book of Discipline.”
In November of the previous year, the South Carolina Conference filed a lawsuit against The Methodist Church of Simpsonville after the church attempted to separate without following the designated procedures for disaffiliation. The Conference’s suit contends that Simpsonville’s departure was unauthorized and thus the properties and assets in question should revert to the Conference.
Since the introduction of temporary provisions allowing disaffiliation, over 200 churches have successfully separated from the United Methodist Church. However, this provision expired on December 31, 2023, leaving at least 40 other churches facing similar legal challenges regarding their separation from the South Carolina Conference.
The Methodist Church of Simpsonville maintains that the lawsuit against them should be dismissed, contending that such matters should fall under the realm of religious law rather than civil jurisdiction. As of now, no trial date or discovery deadline has been established for the ongoing cases, leaving many affected congregations uncertain about their future.
This decision by the South Carolina Supreme Court sets a significant legal precedent that will impact how disputes over church separations and property claims are resolved in the future, especially in light of the growing divide over issues of inclusivity and governance within the United Methodist Church.
Background on Church Disaffiliation
The United Methodist Church has faced increasing tensions regarding its membership and policies, particularly concerning the inclusion of LGBTQ individuals. Churches that have disaffiliated have often cited a desire to uphold traditional beliefs as their primary reason for separating. The recent legal battles illustrate how these theological divides manifest in complicated legal and property disputes.
Current Status of Legal Proceedings
The consolidation of cases by the South Carolina Supreme Court indicates an effort to manage the multitude of disaffiliation cases more effectively. Church leaders and congregations are watching closely as the legal framework surrounding these disputes evolves.
FAQ Section
What was the recent decision by the South Carolina Supreme Court regarding United Methodist churches?
The court ruled not to entertain a motion for original jurisdiction and allowed cases regarding disaffiliated churches to be consolidated in lower courts for a single judge to resolve the disputes.
Why are churches seeking disaffiliation from the United Methodist Church?
Many churches are seeking disaffiliation due to disagreements over the inclusion of LGBTQ members and other theological and governance issues, prompting them to align with different denominations that reflect their beliefs.
How many churches have successfully disaffiliated from the United Methodist Church as of now?
Over 200 churches have successfully disaffiliated from the United Methodist Church under temporary provisions that have expired as of December 31, 2023.
What is the trust clause relating to church properties?
The trust clause is a legal provision that allows church properties and assets to be held in trust for the denomination, which complicates the disaffiliation process, as churches must navigate these legal constraints during separation.
Key Features of the South Carolina Supreme Court Decision
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Supreme Court Ruling | Dismissed original jurisdiction motion, allowing consolidation in lower courts. |
| Case Consolidation | Multiple church cases to be handled by one judge. |
| Disaffiliation Cases | Over 200 churches have separated; at least 40 more face disputes. |
| Legal Context | Disputes largely stem from differences over LGBTQ inclusion and property trust clauses. |
| Current Status | No trial date or discovery deadline established yet. |
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- Post and Courier: SC Supreme Court Ruling on UMC Disaffiliation
- WBTV: Teenager Shot Outside South Carolina Church
- AL.com: UMC Closes 27 Churches in South Alabama
- Owensboro Times: Freddie Lynn Mahan Obituary
- WYFF4: Deputies Conducting Death Investigation
- Wikipedia: United Methodist Church
- Google Search: United Methodist Church Disaffiliation
- Google Scholar: United Methodist Church Lawsuits
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Methodism
- Google News: United Methodist Church
Author: STAFF HERE LEXINGTON WRITER
The LEXINGTON STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HERELexington.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Lexington, Fayette County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Woodland Art Fair, Crave Food and Music Festival, and Railbird Festival. Our coverage extends to key organizations like Commerce Lexington and Blue Grass Community Foundation, plus leading businesses in education, manufacturing, and technology that power the local economy such as University of Kentucky, Toyota Motor Manufacturing, and Lexmark. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREBowlingGreen.com and HERELouisville.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Kentucky's dynamic landscape.
